The Slow Pace of Feeder Automation

Transmission & Distribution World September 1999

By Chuck Newton, Automation Editor


The mandate to serve will continue to lie with the electric distribution entity in our new deregulated world. If you have any doubts, just look at the current federal and state level boards of inquiry that are being established to look into a few recent outages in key areas of the United States. Presently, these boards are not reviewing the status of generation, nor are they focusing their efforts on transmission, but they are clearly intent on assessing the role of distribution operations. These boards will undoubtedly note that the industry if relying on control principles and technology that has matured over the last three decades, but has not grown to the point where the distribution network is monitored and remotely controlled as a system, let alone centrally managed.

Limiting the effects and duration of unplanned outages is a top concern for many distribution operations managers around the world. We are seeing some progress in areas such as supervisory control, data acquisition and distribution management systems applications. However, in terms of distribution automation and the implementation of intelligent electronic devices in the field, growth is not constant among utility segments. In addition, it seems to move in fits and starts, represented by a few large procurements here and there around the world, along with a few hundred pilot programs.

Let’s now take a closer look at the dimensions of the distribution feeder market. There are likely to be more than 750,000 primary distribution feeders energized in the world as you read this article, and as the lights come on in developing nations of the world, this number will grow to more than one million units.

The majority of today’s feeders are overhead. In the United States, as one example, the ratio is about 5-to-1, overhead to underground, with the majority of new feeder installations being underground. The “typical” feeder has at least three switching devices in place along the feeder route. These devices include reclosers, sectionalizers, disconnecting switches, air brake switches and fuses. Around the world, there are a few million reclosers and switches installed for feeder operations, control and management. This is in addition to the millions of installed fuses in several distribution network implementations.

Large utilities operate a thousand or more distribution feeders. In the United States, even mid-sized public power and cooperative utilities typically will operate more than 100 distribution feeders. There are about 50,000 utility-operated distribution substations installed in the United States, and about 250,000 on a worldwide basis.

In overhead applications, reclosers are widely used as switching devices, with sectionalizers next in importance. For underground feeder applications, pad switches are commonly used, with manually operated switches also of importance. Indoor switchgear often supplements the use of pad switched in North America. Fuses, vaults, submersible switches also are used in conjunction with underground feeders.

Where feeder automation programs have been justified, this typically has been to improve the performance of the utility’s worst performing feeders, followed by a reduction in operating costs. Many utilities are developing feeder management strategies. In addition to the role of improving feeder performance, the issue of high-quality service to key accounts is vital. Today, the strategy of improving overall network performance as part of any substation automation strategy should be linked with feeder automation programs, which are dependent on substation automation to some extent, if the full potential of feeder automation is to be realized.

Distribution operations managers may want to move forward with more automation programs sooner rather than later. After all, “boards of inquiry” are not something that we need to hear much about with all of the other changes permeating the electric power industry at this time.